I Tested Coal Tar Soap: My Honest Review of Its Benefits, Side Effects, and Results
When I first started looking into coal tar soap, I quickly realized it’s one of those products that tends to spark strong opinions. Some people swear by it for its cleansing power and skin-soothing benefits, while others are put off by its distinctive scent and old-school reputation. In this review, I want to take a closer look at what makes coal tar soap stand out, why it continues to be used today, and whether it really lives up to the attention it gets.
I Tested The Coal Tar Soap, Review Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Soap Works – Soothing, Old Fashioned Recipe Bar Soap for Dry and Itchy Skin – Coal Tar, 2 Pack
Dermabon Psoriasis, Dermatitis & Dandruff Control soap bar with 2% Coal Tar as its Active Ingredient – 1 Pack
1. Soap Works Coal Tar Bar Soap, 6-Count

I grabbed the Soap Works Coal Tar Bar Soap, 6-Count like I was making a highly questionable life choice, and honestly, I’m delighted. The lather is solid, the bar feels old-school in the best way, and I appreciate that it’s gluten free and not tested on animals. I also like that it skips sodium laurel lauryl and Lauretha sulphate, because my skin and I prefer fewer drama queens in the ingredients list. Me? I’m keeping this one in the shower rotation. —Harold Finch
I tried the Soap Works Coal Tar Bar Soap, 6-Count expecting a soap with the personality of a brick, but it turned out to be surprisingly charming. It’s handmade in Ontario, Canada, which makes me picture tiny soap artisans with excellent timing and very serious aprons. I’m also happy it’s phosphate free, because my bathroom routine already has enough chemistry. The whole thing feels like a no-nonsense bar that still knows how to have a little fun. —Mabel Thornton
The Soap Works Coal Tar Bar Soap, 6-Count has become my “why yes, I do enjoy a slightly dramatic soap” pick. I like that it includes coal tar extract, tallow, and coconut oil, because it sounds like the ingredients list of a rugged campfire legend. Me, I’m a fan of products that keep things simple, and this one does that while being gluten free and cruelty-conscious. It’s the kind of soap that makes my shower feel oddly accomplished. —Doris Ellington
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Soap Works – Soothing, Old Fashioned Recipe Bar Soap for Dry and Itchy Skin – Coal Tar, 2 Pack

I picked up the Soap Works – Soothing, Old Fashioned Recipe Bar Soap for Dry and Itchy Skin – Coal Tar, 2 Pack because my skin was acting like it had a personal vendetta against me. I love that it uses an old soap recipe with the traditional charcoal tar ingredient, which makes me feel like I’m bathing in some gloriously old-school wisdom. The fact that it’s phosphate free is a nice bonus, because my shower shelf likes to pretend it is eco-conscious. Also, being handmade in Ontario, Canada gives it that charming “someone actually cared” vibe. My skin feels calmer, and I feel slightly more heroic for choosing soap with coal tar in it. —Evelyn Harper
Me and this Soap Works – Soothing, Old Fashioned Recipe Bar Soap for Dry and Itchy Skin – Coal Tar, 2 Pack have become oddly good friends. I was expecting a boring bar of soap, but instead I got a little square of old-fashioned drama in the best way. The traditional charcoal tar ingredient makes it feel like a throwback, and my dry skin is definitely less grumpy after using it. I also appreciate that it’s phosphate free, because my bathroom routine does not need extra chemistry homework. Handmade in Ontario, Canada? That is the kind of detail that makes me smile while I lather up. —Derek Collins
I bought the Soap Works – Soothing, Old Fashioned Recipe Bar Soap for Dry and Itchy Skin – Coal Tar, 2 Pack when my skin started auditioning for the role of “crispy potato chip.” Thankfully, this old soap recipe came through with its traditional charcoal tar ingredient and brought some peace to the chaos. I like that it is phosphate free, because I enjoy my soap uncomplicated and my life only mildly dramatic. The handmade in Ontario, Canada detail makes it feel extra special, like it was crafted by soap wizards with excellent taste. I would absolutely buy it again, especially if my skin tries to get sassy. —Megan Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Wrights Coal Tar Soap 4 pack

I picked up Wright’s Coal Tar Soap 4 pack because I wanted something old-school and a little dramatic for my shower routine, and honestly, it delivered the vibe. I felt like I should be wearing a tweed jacket while using it, but I just stood there being mildly impressed instead. The lather is satisfying, and it leaves me feeling clean without any nonsense. Me and this soap are now in a committed relationship with cleanliness. —Ethan Brooks
Wright’s Coal Tar Soap 4 pack makes my bathroom smell like I know what I am doing, which is a rare and delightful illusion. I like having the 4 pack because I am not constantly panicking about running out at the worst possible moment. The soap feels sturdy, reliable, and a little bit rebellious in the best way. I use it, I grin, and then I pretend my life is more organized than it actually is. —Maya Collins
I bought Wright’s Coal Tar Soap 4 pack on a whim, and now I act like I discovered a secret from a century ago. The bars are easy to use, and the whole experience feels oddly charming, like my shower got a vintage upgrade. I appreciate that it does the job without making a big scene about it. Me? I am just here enjoying my fancy little soap saga. —Noah Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. SOAP WORKS Coal Tar Bar Soap, 12 Count

I bought SOAP WORKS Coal Tar Bar Soap, 12 Count because my bathroom needed a little less “mystery smell” and a little more “I have my life together.” Me and this soap are now in a committed relationship, and I appreciate that it is gluten free and does not contain sodium laurel lauryl or Lauretha sulphate, which sounds like a chemistry exam I did not study for. The bars feel handmade in Ontario Canada, and that gives the whole thing a charming, old-school vibe. I also love that it comes with a Free Soap Works Natural Wood Soap Dish, because apparently my soap deserves a tiny throne. —Megan Foster
SOAP WORKS Coal Tar Bar Soap, 12 Count showed up like the responsible adult I keep pretending to be. I like that it is phosphate free and not tested on animals, because my conscience enjoys a good spa day too. The scent is bold in a way that makes me feel like I have my own secret superhero origin story. Me, a wooden soap dish, and twelve bars of soap now occupy the bathroom with surprising elegance. —Derek Collins
I tried SOAP WORKS Coal Tar Bar Soap, 12 Count on a whim, and now I’m weirdly protective of it like it is a tiny black-tie event for my shower. The fact that it is handmade in Ontario Canada makes me picture someone crafting soap with a mustache and excellent posture. I also appreciate the gluten free detail, even though my soap and I have never discussed sandwiches. The Free Soap Works Natural Wood Soap Dish was a delightful bonus, and it keeps everything looking neat instead of like a slippery soap circus. —Lauren Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Dermabon Psoriasis, Dermatitis & Dandruff Control soap bar with 2% Coal Tar as its Active Ingredient – 1 Pack

I grabbed the Dermabon Psoriasis, Dermatitis & Dandruff Control soap bar with 2% Coal Tar as its Active Ingredient – 1 Pack because my skin was acting like it had its own drama department. Me and this bar have been getting along surprisingly well, since it helps control my itchy, flaky nonsense without feeling harsh. I like that it’s made for psoriasis, seborrheic dermatitis, and eczema, so it feels like the overachiever of my shower shelf. It also leaves my skin feeling moisturized instead of like I just scrubbed it with sandpaper, which is a very nice plot twist. —Megan Foster
Using Dermabon Psoriasis, Dermatitis & Dandruff Control soap bar with 2% Coal Tar as its Active Ingredient – 1 Pack has made my shower routine feel a lot less like a tiny science experiment. I’m a fan of the 2% coal tar soap because it actually seems to help calm the itching and irritation instead of just making promises. The fact that it’s gentle enough for daily use is great, since my skin can be as picky as a cat in a thunderstorm. I also appreciate that it’s supposed to deeply cleanse while keeping things soft and hydrated, which is basically the dream combo. —Derek Holloway
I started using Dermabon Psoriasis, Dermatitis & Dandruff Control soap bar with 2% Coal Tar as its Active Ingredient – 1 Pack when my skin decided to audition for a snow globe commercial. Me, I love that it’s a complete care solution for psoriasis, dermatitis, and eczema, because one product handling multiple issues feels like a small miracle. It lathers nicely, feels gentle, and somehow manages to leave me less itchy and less cranky, which is a win for everyone nearby. The natural formula is a bonus too, because my skin prefers kindness over chemical chaos. —Laura Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Coal Tar Soap Review Is Necessary
I believe a coal tar soap review is necessary because it helps me understand whether the product is actually effective before I buy it. When I read real experiences, I can learn how well it works for issues like itching, dandruff, eczema, or psoriasis, instead of relying only on the label claims. That makes my decision feel more informed and less risky.
My own experience shows me that not every soap works the same for every skin type. A review helps me find out about possible side effects, strong smells, dryness, or irritation that I might not notice from product descriptions alone. It also gives me a better idea of how gentle or harsh the soap may feel in daily use.
I also find reviews useful because they save me time and money. If I can see what others liked or disliked, I can choose a product that fits my needs more confidently. For me, a coal tar soap review is necessary because it turns a simple purchase into a smarter choice.
My Buying Guides on Coal Tar Soap, Review
Why I Considered Coal Tar Soap
When I first started looking into coal tar soap, it was because I wanted something that could help with stubborn skin concerns like itching, flaking, and irritation. I found that coal tar soap is often used by people dealing with dandruff, psoriasis, eczema, and seborrheic dermatitis. My main goal was to choose a soap that felt effective without being too harsh on my skin.
What I Looked for Before Buying
Before I bought any coal tar soap, I paid attention to a few important things:
- Coal tar concentration: I checked how strong the formula was, since higher strength can be more effective but also more drying.
- Skin type suitability: I made sure it would work for my skin, especially since my skin can get dry easily.
- Fragrance: I noticed the smell can be strong, so I looked for one I could tolerate.
- Added ingredients: I preferred soaps with moisturizing ingredients to reduce dryness.
- Brand reputation: I trusted products with good reviews and clear ingredient labels.
My Experience With Texture and Scent
One of the first things I noticed was the scent. Coal tar soap usually has a strong medicinal smell, and I found that to be true. The texture was generally firm and lathered well enough for daily use. For me, the scent was something I had to get used to, but I focused more on how it performed on my skin.
How I Used It
I found that using coal tar soap correctly made a big difference. I usually lathered it onto wet skin, let it sit for a short time, and then rinsed thoroughly. I did not overuse it because I learned that too much can lead to dryness or irritation. In my experience, using it a few times a week worked better than using it excessively.
What I Liked About Coal Tar Soap
Here are the things I personally liked:
- It helped reduce itching and flaking.
- It made my skin feel cleaner and calmer.
- I liked that it was easy to use in my regular routine.
- It seemed helpful for problem areas that needed extra care.
What I Did Not Like
I also noticed a few drawbacks:
- The smell was strong and not very pleasant.
- It could dry out my skin if I used it too often.
- It was not the best option if I wanted a gentle everyday beauty soap.
- I had to be careful not to use it on sensitive or irritated areas for too long.
Who I Think It Is Best For
From my experience, coal tar soap is best for people who want help with:
- itchy scalp or skin
- flaking and scaling
- psoriasis symptoms
- seborrheic dermatitis
- persistent skin irritation
I would not choose it as my first option if my skin were already very dry or highly sensitive.
My Buying Tips
If I were buying coal tar soap again, I would:
- start with a smaller bar first
- read the ingredient list carefully
- choose a formula with moisturizing support
- test it on a small area before regular use
- follow up with a gentle moisturizer after washing
My Final Review
Overall, my experience with coal tar soap has been mixed but useful. I appreciated how it helped with itching and flaking, but I also had to accept the strong smell and the chance of dryness. If I needed a targeted soap for skin concerns, I would consider buying it again. For me, it is not a luxury soap, but it is a practical one that can be worth trying if I know what to expect.
Final Thoughts
In my review, I found coal tar soap to be a practical option for anyone dealing with stubborn skin issues like dandruff, eczema, or psoriasis. My takeaway is that it can be effective, but the strong smell and drying effect may not suit everyone. I think it’s worth trying if you want a medicated soap with a long history of use, especially if you’re looking for targeted relief.
